It’s Season One of Sex and the City, and Samantha refers to a cute little Fixer-Upper. If you don’t recall, she’s describing the Turtle.

That’s Bernie Turtletaub to be precise – far from every woman’s dream – complete with balding dome, nerdy glasses, boring babble regardless of topic, and notoriously nasty breath. But he seems kindly enough (and has deep pockets); theoretically he’s the ideal target for a woman looking to “fix” a man – transforming him into what she imagines he could be.

Fixer-Upper Relationships

Think it’s just women who play this game? Trying to change the man they’re dating? Think again. 

I have an old friend who falls for younger (unsophisticated) women. He refashions their sense of style, buys them a new wardrobe, instructs them in wine and food, and once these Eliza Doolittles are ready to stand on their own, invariably – they leave him.

Personally, I’ve never been attracted to Fixer-Uppers. I don’t believe in dating a man with the objective of changing him. Life is challenging enough without turning a person into a project – especially when you’re raising kids, which involves projects enough – thank you very much.

Besides, when you fall in love with a Fixer-Upper, aren’t you falling in love with what you think the person will be? With an idea or an illusion? How can it possibly work?

Fixer-Upper Homes

As for a Fixer-Upper home?

For me, that’s a different tale entirely. If you’re a Do-It-Yourself enthusiast – even if you aren’t – you understand the thrill of building on good bones and recreating your environment exactly as you would like it.

If you manage with a small budget, you also understand. Besides, conventional wisdom says – better to purchase the least expensive home on the block than the most expensive – and over time, fix it up.

My own little home qualifies as a Fixer-Upper – at least it did, when we moved in – older, solid foundation, good location, and ample options for tweaking this and expanding that. My boys and I have done our share of fixing up around here, with no shortage of possible projects in the future.

Date a Man So You Can Change Him?

But unlike the prospect of dating a Fixer-Upper guy, or for that matter, being the woman a man would like to change, I love the creativity of a home with the promise of possibilities – sprucing up the deck by potting some plants, brightening a bathroom with a coat of paint and new towel racks, the “some day” vision of a bay window here, or an expanded entry there. (Maybe even my Parisian courtyard?)

The pleasure? It’s in the imagining, as much as the doing.

Anytime I’ve undertaken a house project, even if it’s small, I’ve experienced a surge of energy in the renovation process. Fixing up my space feels hopeful, like an investment in the future.

But fixing up another person? Dating a man so I can change him?

No thanks.

  • Are you big on Fixer-Upper men or women? What happens when they’re “fixed?”
  • Are you a Do-It-Yourself person, always dreaming up projects around the house, the apartment, or the garden?


You May Also Enjoy



  1. says

    Forget it. It doesn’t happen. People can grow and mature, and this can be one of the blessings of a right relationship, but that’s not what we’re talking here. We’re talking about one person imposing their will on another. Forget it.

  2. says

    Do it yourself fixing in a home, yes. It’s fun (after the exhaustion and possible despair) to see what you have made.

    As for people, I don’t think so. Real changes come from within.

  3. says

    Supporting someone in their own efforts to become the way they want to be – to be their best, that is love. Trying to fix someone, to make them into what you want, that’s self-centred.

  4. says

    I can’t even fathom that type of thought process – why one would undertake such an endeavor. I wonder, these fixer-upper types, what attracts them to the person in the first place. Are they truly attracted or do they feel some motivation to have a “project”; to prove themselves as a “savior” of sorts?

    • BigLittleWolf says

      It stupefies me, Cathy. But I’ve actually known quite a few women with these tendencies, and only that one gentleman I mentioned who routinely engages in fixer-upper encounters. I suspect there’s an element of control involved.

      But personally? I don’t get it.

  5. says

    I delight in fixing up my garden and home. I am truly exhilarated when the first new bloom of a previously planted bulb emerges in spring. I also dream of reading nooks and bold color palettes in different rooms of my house.

    This is where I end my fixing up pleasure. I am not a woman who cares to fix up a man. I accept mine for who he is, was and will be. But the “will be” is most definitely up to him.

    A delightful read here. I enjoyed musing about gardens and such.


  6. says

    I dusted my guy off and helped his personality shine, but he’s the same guy he was before we met. I don’t have the time or energy to fix anyone, especially they person who’s supposed to be my partner.

    And when it comes to houses? I have no interest. I wish I cared more in the way things look. I just want them comfortable and clean. (Kinda like my men?)

  7. says

    I’m a build it from scratch kind of person. I don’t want to fix a man (as you brilliantly point out, that’s the last thing I have energy for while trying to mold yet protect the selfhood of little people). I don’t really want to fix a house. I have, since nothing exists that I don’t want to art up a bit, and I loved it. But I’d rather go back to school for an architecture degree, draw up plans, go *back* to school for a carpentry degree, build my house, go back to school again for my electrician’s certifiwhozit…you get the picture. I’m a hands-on, get out of my way, can’t delegate, perfectionist kind of jackass. Maybe someone will try to fix *me*.

    Now THAT sounds kind of nice. 😉

    • BigLittleWolf says

      Oh, now you’re talking, Ms. Naptime. What could be better than a lifetime of learning? Don’t fix that! It’s good stuff!

  8. says

    It’s too time consuming to fix another person. In reality, I am striving to better myself so that I can adjust my reaction toward others. I think if you feel the need to fix someone, you must reevaluate why you chose the relationship in the first place.

  9. says

    I think the only person I try to “fix up” is myself … and some days, I’m pretty sure that’s not very wise either. And I do love fixing up a space, though the potential for frustration always looms. Why can’t those damn knickknacks on those damn shelves look like the ones on Pinterest, dammit! =>

  10. says

    So, it occurs to me that as I am an editor in my day-job life, I might be drawn to try to fix other things: men, structures. Not so. It is as if my fixing someone else’s poor sentence structure I get all the practice I need. My partner in this life is who he is, and we are a good match. Both of us could use improvements, I am sure. Our house is a messy disaster in need of major repairs and other more subtle improvements. Bottom line: We’re happy. With each other. And in our home. :) Thanks for this, Wolfie.


  1. […] Recently, Big Little Wolf wrote an article on her blog about “fixer-uppers” – people who want to change other people they consider “fixer-uppers” and the legitimate fixer-upper – a house.  Her conclusion as it relates to people is:  “How can it possibly work?”  But fixing up a house: “feels hopeful, like an investment in the future.” […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge